Robo-Advisors vs. DIY Investing: What's the Difference
June 26, 2026
Once your debt is paid off, or well under control, and you're ready to start investing, one of the first practical decisions is how much you want to manage yourself. Broadly, the choice comes down to two approaches: a robo-advisor that builds and manages a portfolio for you, or a self-directed brokerage account where you pick your own investments.
How a robo-advisor works
A robo-advisor asks you a set of questions about your goals, timeline, and risk tolerance, then builds and automatically rebalances a diversified portfolio for you, typically made up of low-cost exchange-traded funds. You contribute money and the platform handles the rest — choosing the mix, rebalancing over time, and often offering the account inside a TFSA or RRSP wrapper. Wealthsimple is a well-known example of a Canadian robo-advisor, and there are a handful of others offering broadly similar automated portfolios.
This article includes a referral link to Wealthsimple. If you sign up through it, we may both receive a bonus — that doesn't cost you anything extra, and it's why we mention it openly rather than just linking without saying so. See how this link works for the full details.
How DIY investing works
A self-directed brokerage account gives you full control: you choose individual stocks, ETFs, or other securities, and you decide when to buy, sell, and rebalance. It typically has lower fees than a managed robo-advisor portfolio, since you're not paying for portfolio management — but it requires more time, more knowledge, and more discipline to avoid emotional decisions during market swings.
Comparing the trade-offs
- Fees: robo-advisors usually charge a small annual management fee on top of the underlying fund costs; DIY investing avoids that management fee but still has fund costs and trading considerations
- Time: a robo-advisor is largely hands-off after setup; DIY investing rewards ongoing attention and research
- Control: DIY gives you full say over what you hold; a robo-advisor makes those calls within the risk profile you selected
- Behaviour: automated rebalancing can help remove the temptation to react emotionally to market swings, which is a real risk for self-directed investors
Neither is objectively better
Someone who wants to learn about markets and enjoys managing their own portfolio may prefer the control of DIY investing. Someone who wants a sound, diversified portfolio without spending time managing it may prefer a robo-advisor's simplicity, even at a slightly higher fee. Some people use both — a robo-advisor for a core long-term holding and a small self-directed account for individual picks they want to follow more closely.
This article is educational and isn't personalized financial or investment advice — talk to a licensed financial professional about what's appropriate for your own goals and risk tolerance.