← Back to the blog
Debt Payoff Strategies

High-Interest Debt vs. Low-Interest Debt: Which to Attack First

August 4, 2025

One of the most common mistakes in debt payoff isn't failing to pay extra — it's spreading that extra evenly across every debt instead of concentrating it where it does the most good. Not all debt is created equal, and treating a 22% credit card the same as a 4% car loan leaves real money on the table.

What counts as "high interest"

There's no single official cutoff, but a useful rough line is anything in the high teens or above — credit cards, most retail store cards, and many personal or payday loans typically live here. Anything meaningfully above what you could reasonably expect from long-term investing is worth treating as urgent, because paying it off is effectively a guaranteed return equal to its interest rate.

What counts as "low interest"

  • Mortgages — typically the lowest rate most people carry, often in the low-to-mid single digits to high single digits depending on the rate environment.
  • Many car loans and lines of credit, particularly with good credit.
  • Government student loans, which sometimes carry reduced or subsidized rates depending on the program and your province.

Why the split matters so much

Interest compounds, so the gap between a 22% card and a 5% loan isn't just "a bit more" — it's dramatically more over time. Say you have $6,000 sitting on a 22% card and $6,000 left on a 5% car loan: every month you delay attacking the card costs you roughly four times as much in interest as the same delay on the loan. Extra payments spread evenly across both waste that difference instead of capturing it.

A practical approach

Keep minimum payments current on everything — missing a payment on a low-interest debt still damages your credit and can trigger fees, regardless of its rate. Then direct every extra dollar at the highest-interest balance until it's gone, and only then move to the next highest. This is the avalanche method, and it's specifically built around the high-interest-first logic described here. If a low-interest debt bothers you psychologically more than the math justifies — a car loan cosigned with a parent, say — that's a legitimate reason to deviate, but it's worth being clear-eyed that you're trading some interest savings for peace of mind, not that the math changed.

Once the high-interest debt is cleared, the remaining low-interest balances usually don't need the same urgency. It's often reasonable to pay those down on their normal schedule while redirecting some of what used to be extra payments toward savings or investing instead.

Ready to build your own payoff plan?

MyBudgetMaker turns your real numbers into a month-by-month schedule — free to start.