← Back to the blog
Saving & Emergency Funds

Building an Emergency Fund While You're Still in Debt

November 19, 2024

There's a persistent belief that saving money while you still carry debt is somehow irresponsible — that every spare dollar should go straight to your balances until they're at zero. In practice, that approach often backfires, because it leaves you with no buffer for the unexpected expense that inevitably shows up, forcing you right back onto a credit card to cover it.

Why a small cushion changes the math

Consider two people who both put $200 a month toward extra debt payments. One of them has zero savings; the other has kept $500 aside. When a $400 car repair shows up, the first person puts it on a credit card, adding new high-interest debt right back onto the balance they were working so hard to reduce. The second person pays cash from their cushion and simply rebuilds it over the following months. Over a year, the person with even a small buffer often makes more real progress, because they aren't repeatedly undoing their own work.

A practical starter approach

  1. Build a small starter emergency fund first — even $500 to $1,000 covers a lot of common surprises
  2. Once that's in place, shift the majority of your extra payment toward debt, using avalanche or snowball
  3. Keep contributing a small, steady amount to savings alongside debt payments, rather than pausing it entirely
  4. After debt is cleared, redirect the full former debt payment into building a fuller 3-to-6-month emergency fund

The exact split is a personal call — some people prefer 90% to debt and 10% to savings, others go closer to 80/20. What matters more than the precise ratio is that both categories exist in the budget at the same time, rather than treating them as sequential, all-or-nothing phases.

Where to actually keep this money

An emergency fund should be liquid and boring — a high-interest savings account you can access within a day or two, kept separate from your everyday chequing account so it's not tempting to dip into for non-emergencies. It doesn't need to earn a great return; its entire job is to be there when you need it, not to grow aggressively. Some people use a TFSA for this since withdrawals are tax-free and flexible, though a plain high-interest savings account works just as well for a short-term cushion.

The mindset shift that helps most

Think of your emergency fund not as competing with your debt payoff, but as insurance for it — its whole purpose is to protect the progress you're making from being wiped out by the next surprise expense. A cushion that keeps you from adding new debt is, in a very real sense, still part of your debt-payoff strategy.

Ready to build your own payoff plan?

MyBudgetMaker turns your real numbers into a month-by-month schedule — free to start.